Headlines

In 2019, a North Carolina property owner says flooding from a 361-home development battered her land and fences; seven years later, an appeals court has rejected the city’s immunity defence

In 2019, a North Carolina property owner says flooding from a 361-home development battered her land and fences; seven years later, an appeals court has rejected the city's immunity defence


In 2019, a North Carolina property owner says flooding from a 361-home development battered her land and fences; seven years later, an appeals court has rejected the city's immunity defence
Representative Image (AI-generated)

A North Carolina property owner who accused a city of allowing stormwater from a large residential development to repeatedly flood her land has won an important procedural victory after years of litigation. The dispute began in 2019, when a flash flood allegedly sent several feet of muddy water, construction debris and other material onto her property, damaging fences and an underground stormwater pipe.In a November 18, 2026, decision available on Justia, the North Carolina Court of Appeals upheld a lower court’s refusal to dismiss the claims against the City of Concord on governmental immunity grounds. The judges ruled that the city’s stormwater management activities were proprietary functions rather than governmental functions, meaning the city could not use governmental immunity to avoid the negligence, trespass and private nuisance claims at this stage. The decision allows the lawsuit to proceed but does not establish that the city was responsible for the alleged damage.

Flash floods followed construction of 361-home development

The case, Moss v. City of Concord, involved Jaylene Moss and RWJ Consulting Inc., whose property was located in Concord, North Carolina. The City of Concord owned an easement for underground pipes running through their land. In 2014, the city approved plans for a residential development south of the property that would eventually consist of 361 large, single-family homes. It approved the second and third phases of the development in 2016.According to the plaintiffs’ complaint, a rainstorm in 2019 caused a flash flood during construction, sending several feet of brown water from the development site onto their property. The flooding allegedly carried wood debris and discarded fast-food cups from the construction area, washed away sections of the northern fence and destroyed the southern fence.The property owners also alleged that the force of the water, combined with tree debris from the construction site, caused an underground stormwater pipe beneath their front yard to buckle and break. The damage reportedly created a hole measuring approximately two feet by two feet. The problem did not end with the first incident. The plaintiffs alleged that several additional flash floods occurred between 2020 and 2024, continuing to affect their property.

Property owners accused city of inadequate stormwater management

In 2022, Moss and RWJ Consulting filed a lawsuit against the City of Concord and several other parties involved in the development. These included Tac Niblock LLC, Landworks Design Group PA, The Ardent Companies LLC, CMG Builders Inc. and Hunton Forest Homeowner’s Association Inc. The complaint included claims of negligence, trespass and private nuisance. The plaintiffs alleged that the city had approved the development’s stormwater design without ensuring that the system could adequately manage the volume and flow of water generated by construction.They also accused the city of failing to monitor the stormwater system, enforce maintenance requirements and prevent recurring overflows onto their land. In addition, they brought an inverse condemnation claim, arguing that the city’s actions had effectively resulted in a taking of their property. The city sought dismissal, arguing that governmental immunity protected it from the claims. However, on June 4, 2025, the Cabarrus County Superior Court denied the city’s motion, finding that the complaint contained claims on which relief could be granted. The city then appealed that decision.

Appeals court distinguishes governmental and proprietary functions

The central question before the appeals court was whether the city’s involvement in stormwater management qualified as a governmental function protected by immunity. Under North Carolina law, municipalities generally enjoy governmental immunity when performing governmental functions. However, that protection does not automatically extend to proprietary activities, which are commercial or undertaken primarily for the private advantage of a community.The court noted that North Carolina law classifies stormwater management as a public enterprise under N.C. General Statutes Section 160A-311(10). It also relied on a 2024 decision, Devonwood-Loch Lomond Lake Association Inc. v. City of Fayetteville, in which the court had ruled that stormwater management was a proprietary municipal function and that related negligence, trespass and nuisance claims were not barred by governmental immunity.Applying the same reasoning, the judges concluded that the allegations against Concord concerned its proprietary stormwater management activities. Therefore, the city could not rely on governmental immunity to obtain dismissal of those claims.

Lawsuit can proceed, but liability remains undecided

The North Carolina Court of Appeals affirmed the lower court’s June 2025 order denying the city’s motion to dismiss on governmental immunity grounds. However, the judges declined to consider the city’s separate challenge to the inverse condemnation claim because that issue was not properly before them in the interlocutory appeal. They also denied the city’s request for discretionary review of that issue.The ruling does not determine whether the city negligently handled stormwater management or whether it must compensate the property owners. Those questions remain for further proceedings. The decision means that the plaintiffs can continue pursuing their negligence, trespass and nuisance claims without the city using governmental immunity as a defence at this stage.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *