Headlines

John D Rockefeller Jr created a trust for his granddaughter in 1943, but she later challenged JPMorgan’s 1967 sale of oil stocks; a New York appeals court rejected her claim that the bank mishandled the family assets

John D Rockefeller Jr created a trust for his granddaughter in 1943, but she later challenged JPMorgan's 1967 sale of oil stocks; a New York appeals court rejected her claim that the bank mishandled the family assets


John D Rockefeller Jr created a trust for his granddaughter in 1943, but she later challenged JPMorgan's 1967 sale of oil stocks; a New York appeals court rejected her claim that the bank mishandled the family assets
FILE PHOTO: People walk near the JPMorgan Chase & Co., headquarters in New York City.

A New York appeals court has rejected a legal challenge by the granddaughter of oil tycoon John D Rockefeller Jr, who accused JPMorgan Chase of mishandling her family trust by selling oil company stocks in 1967 and investing the proceeds in riskier securities. The court upheld a lower court’s decision approving the bank’s accounting of the trust and releasing it from liability over its management of the assets between 1962 and 2012.The case involved a trust established in 1943 by Rockefeller Jr for his granddaughter, Dr Lucy Rockefeller Waletzky. JPMorgan Chase, formerly known as The Chase National Bank of the City of New York, was appointed trustee under an agreement dated December 27, 1943.In its November 19 ruling, the Appellate Division of the New York Supreme Court’s First Department unanimously dismissed Waletzky’s objections, finding that she had failed to establish that the bank’s records were incomplete or that its investment decisions were imprudent.Why Rockefeller’s granddaughter challenged JPMorganUnder the terms of the trust, Waletzky was entitled to receive its accumulated net income after turning 21 in March 1962. Decades later, in 2016, she filed objections to the bank’s accounting, alleging that JPMorgan had failed to maintain accurate records and breached its fiduciary duty by not investing the trust’s assets prudently.A central part of her challenge concerned the bank’s 1967 sale of shares in several oil companies. Waletzky argued that the decision amounted to a breach of the duty of loyalty and self-dealing because the bank had allegedly acted to benefit its own business interests rather than the trust.She claimed that the oil companies were generating unprecedented revenues and paying record dividends when their shares were sold. According to her objections, JPMorgan subsequently invested the proceeds in a collection of riskier, lower-yielding securities, including shares in companies that had business relationships with the bank.She further alleged that the bank had extended loans to some of these companies, several of the investments were eventually sold at a net loss, and the sale of the oil stocks created a substantial tax liability for the trust.Court says bank’s investment strategy was prudentThe appeals court, however, found that JPMorgan had provided sufficient evidence to demonstrate that it had properly accounted for its management of the trust.The bank submitted its accounting records along with a supporting affidavit stating that the schedules of trust assets were accurate and complete. This shifted the burden to Waletzky to establish, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the accounting was incomplete or inaccurate.The court noted that witnesses for JPMorgan had testified that maintaining transaction records and investment diaries was standard industry practice when the bank managed the trust. They also said the records produced were typical and adequate. Waletzky failed to refute their testimony, the judges observed.On the investment dispute, the court found that there was sufficient evidence to support the bank’s diversification strategy under the applicable standards governing trust investments.It said Waletzky had relied largely on hindsight to argue that selling the high-performing oil stocks and purchasing other securities was an imprudent decision.The judges also pointed out that the availability of other investment options did not automatically make the bank’s chosen strategy imprudent. The record supported diversification even if, in retrospect, concentrating the trust’s assets in oil company shares might have generated higher returns.The court also rejected the self-dealing allegation, finding that Waletzky had produced no evidence establishing that JPMorgan’s business relationships with companies whose shares it purchased had influenced its investment decisions.The November 19 decision unanimously affirmed the lower court’s order approving JPMorgan’s accounting for the period from March 9, 1962, to June 30, 2012, and releasing the bank from liability concerning the matters covered by the accounting.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *